Identification and Assessment of the Seismic Behaviour of Giotto‘s Bell Tower in Florence (Italy)

Abstract

Among the different typologies of historic buildings, masonry towers represent a hallmark of many European town centres which embody an important heritage to be preserved and passing on to future generations. Giotto’s Bell Tower in Florence together with the Leaning Tower of Pisa and the San Marco Tower in Venice (which collapsed in 1902) is one of the iconic masonry towers ever built in Italy. The assessment of the structural behaviour of these structures, together with the development of proper preservation strategies, has attracted in recent decades the interest of a plethora of scholars. Most of the studies on towers vulnerability focuses on the assessment of their seismic behaviour, since their slenderness exposes them to the dynamic effects induced by medium-to-severe earthquakes. This paper, given this background, discusses the identification and the seismic behaviour of Giotto’s Bell Tower in Florence. In a first part of this paper a refined numerical model, built through the finite element technique based on a recent laser scanning survey, is reported together with the procedure adopted for its modal identification. The finite element model accounts for the soil-structure-interaction. In a second part of this paper the numerical model is employed to perform linear time-history analyses, by using natural accelerograms. The results of the analyses allow to assess the seismic behaviour of the Bell Tower of Giotto and suggest preservation strategies.

Full document

References

[1] Russo, G., Bergamo, O., Damiani, L. and Lugato, D. Experimental analysis of the Saint Andrea Masonry Bell Tower in Venice. A new method for the determination of Tower Global Young's Modulus E. Engineering Structures (2010) 32(2):353-360.

[2] Gentile, C. and Saisi, A. Ambient vibration testing of historic masonry towers for structural identification and damage assessment. Construction and Building Materials (2007) 21(6):1311-1321.

[3] Carpinteri, A., Invernizzi, S. and Lacidogna, G. Numerical assessment of three medieval masonry towers subjected to different loading conditions. Masonry International (2006) 19:65-76

[4] Ivorra, S. and Pallares, F.J. Dynamic investigations on a masonry bell tower. Engineering Structures (2006) 28(5):660-667.

[5] Ivorra, S., Pallarés, F.J. and Adam, J.M. Experimental and numerical results from the seismic study of a masonry bell tower. Advances in Structural Engineering (2009) 12(2):287-293.

[6] Sabia, D., Aoki, T., Cosentini, R.M. and Lancellotta, R. Model updating to forecast the dynamic behavior of the Ghirlandina tower in Modena, Italy. Journal of Earthquake Engineering (2015) 19(1):1-24.

[7] Binda, L., Zanzi, L., Lualdi, M. and Condoleo, P. The use of georadar to assess damage to a masonry bell tower in Cremona, Italy. NDT & E International (2005) 38(3):171–179.

[8] Anzani, A., Binda, L., Carpinteri, A., Invernizzi, S. and Lacidogna, G. A multilevel approach for the damage assessment of historic masonry towers. Journal of Cultural Heritage (2010) 11(4):459-470.

[9] Bartoli, G., Betti, M. and Giordano, S. In situ static and dynamic investigations on the “Torre Grossa” masonry tower. Engineering Structures (2013) 52:718-733.

[10] Ramos, L.F., Marques, L., Lourenço, P.B., De Roeck, G., Campos-Costa, A. and Roque, J. Monitoring historical masonry structures with operational modal analysis: Two case studies. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing (2010) 24(5):1291-1305.

[11] Pieraccini, M., Dei, D., Betti, M., Bartoli, G., Tucci, G. and Guardini, N. Dynamic identification of historic masonry towers through an expeditious and no-contact approach: application to the “Torre del Mangia” in Siena (Italy). Journal of Cultural Heritage (2014) (2014) 15(3):275–282.

[12] Casolo, S. A three dimensional model for vulnerability analyses of slender masonry Medieval towers. Journal of Earthquake Engineering (1998) 2(4):487-512.

[13] Bernardeschi, K., Padovani, C. and Pasquinelli, G. Numerical modelling of the structural behaviour of Buti’s bell tower. Journal Cultural Heritage (2004) 5:371-378.

[14] Peña, F., Lourenço, P.B., Mendez, N. and Oliveira, D. Numerical models for the seismic assessment of an old masonry tower. Engineering Structures (2010) 32:1466-1478.

[15] Milani, G., Casolo, S., Naliato, A. and Tralli, A. Seismic assessment of a medieval masonry tower in Northern Italy by limit, non-linear static and full dynamic analyses. International Journal Architectural Heritage (2012) 6(5):489-524.

[16] D’Ambrisi, A., Mariani, V. and Mezzi, M. Seismic assessment of a historical masonry tower with nonlinear static and dynamic analyses tuned on ambient vibration tests. Engineering Structures (2012) 36:210–219.

[17] Casolo, S., Milani, G., Uva, G. and Alessandri, C. Comparative seismic vulnerability analysis on ten masonry towers in the coastal Po Valley in Italy. Engineering Structures (2013) 49:465–90.

[18] Ferrante, A., Clementi, F., Milani, G. Advanced numerical analyses by the Non-Smooth Contact Dynamics method of an ancient masonry bell tower. Mathematical Methods in the Applied Sciences (2020) 1-20.

[19] Bru, D., Ivorra, S., Betti, M., Adam, J.M., and Bartoli, G. Parametric dynamic interaction assessment between bells and supporting slender masonry tower. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing (2019) 129: 235-249.

[20] Pieraccini, M., Fratini, M., Dei, D., and Atzeni, C. Structural testing of Historical Heritage Site Towers by microwave remote sensing. Journal of Cultural Heritage (2009) 10: 174–182.

[21] Lacanna, G., Ripepe, M., Coli, M., Genco, R., and Marchetti, E. Full structural dynamic response from ambient vibration of Giotto's bell tower in Firenze (Italy), using modal analysis and seismic interferometry. NDT and E International (2019) 102: 9–15.

[22] NTC 2008, Nuove Norme Tecniche per le Costruzioni, G.U. n. 29, 4 Febbraio 2008, S.O. n. 30. D.M. del Ministero delle Infrastrutture e dei Trasporti 14 Gennaio 2008 (in Italian).

[23] MIT 2009, Circolare n. 617 del 2 febbraio 2009. Istruzioni per l’Applicazione Nuove Norme Tecniche Costruzioni di cui al Decreto Ministeriale 14 gennaio 2008 (in Italian).