Geometric and Structural Information for the Analysis of Historical Domes: The Case of the SS. Trinità Church in Torino

Abstract

Investigation into the geometric configuration of historical masonry domes isfundamental when studying the structural behaviour of these architectural elements, above all if they have historical and artistic relevance. Indeed, accurate geometric information is essential also for the construction of reliable mechanical models, to monitor the condition stateof the building and to plan strengthening and conservation interventions. To this aim, a multidisciplinary approach is required to collate the highest possible amount of data useful for the numerical modelling, including historical and archival research. The "SS. Trinità" church is a 16th century building of great historical, architectural and structural significance in the historic centre of Turin. It owes its fame primarily to the architect who built it, Ascanio Vitozzi, and to its large dome, built after the architect’s death. The availability of a recently undertaken laser scanner survey of the intrados of the dome made it possible to detect several depressions of the masonry cap. These findings can be either due to construction defects, or to structural problems that developed over centuries, or to the severefire which struck the dome in 1942. In this multidisciplinary research, different numerical models of the masonry dome of SS.Trinità church were built. As a first step, a geometric study was based on the point cloud from the laser scanning. Then, structural analyses were conducted on the two different models of the dome-tambour system of the building, in order to try to explain the observed deformation behaviour.

Full document

References

[1] De Lucia, G., Ceravolo, R., Chiorino, M.A., Miraglia G., The role of structural health monitoring in the seismic protection of monumental structures: the virtual lab of the sanctuary of Vicoforte,proceeding of VII Structural World Engineering Congress, Istanbul, 24-26 Aprile (2019).

[2] Como, M., Statica delle costruzioni storiche in muratura, Rome, Italy, Aracne Editrice, (2010).

[3] Ottoni F,. Dome Strengthening By Encircling Ties: A Monitored Experiment, Int J Archit Herit. (2015), 9:82-95.

[4] Ottoni, F., Blasi C., Hooping as an ancient remedy for conservation of large masonry domes, Int. J. Archit. Herit., (2015), 10:164-181.

[5] Cavalagli N. & Gusella V., Dome of the Basilica of Santa Maria degli Angeli in Assisi: Static and Dynamic Assessement, Int J Archit Herit (2015), 9: 157-175.

[6] Scotti, A., Ascanio Vitozzi. Ingegnere ducale a Torino, La nuova Italia Editrice, Firenze, (1969), p. 18.

[7] Viglino Davico, M., La chiesa della Santissima Trinità. In Viglino Davico, Ascanio Vitozzi. Ingegnere militare, urbanista, architetto (1539-1615), Quattroemme, Perugia (2003), pp. 231-242.

[8] Ruffino, M. (Eds): Una chiesa per il Ducato, la Ss. Trinità di Torino, Torino, CLUT, (2019).

[9] De Lucia, G., Lenticchia E., Ceravolo R., La geometria della cupola della SS.Trinità: dal dato metrico alle valutazioni strutturali, In Ruffino, M. (Eds): Una chiesa per il Ducato, la Ss. Trinità di Torino, Torino, CLUT, (2019), pp. 117-142.

[10] Pistone G. and Roccati R., Testing of large undistributed sample of old masonry. In Proceeding of the 8th International Brick/Block Masonry Conference, Dublin, 19-21 September (1988).

[11] Drucker D. and Prager W., Soil mechanism and plastic analysis or limit design, Quarterly of Applied Mathematics, (1952), 10:157-165.

[12] Betti, M., Galano, L., Vingoli A., Finite element modelling for seismic assessment of historical masonry buildings. In: D’Amico, S. (Eds), Earthquakes and their impact on society, Springer, Switzerland, (2016), pp. 377-413.

[13] Spina, A., Analisi degli effetti del comportamento a breve e lungo termine di torri in muratura: il caso della torre campanaria del Duomo di Torino. Thesis in Civil Engineering, Politecnico di Torino, 2018.

[14] Cominelli S., Comportamento delle murature storiche al collasso: meccanismi di rottura, effetti del confinamento e fenomeni reologici. PhD Thesis, Università degli studi di Brescia, 2014.