Effect of Geometrical Imperfections on the Response of Dry-Joint Masonry Arches to Support Settlements

Abstract

This paper aims to investigate the effects of geometrical imperfections on the response of a scaled dry-joint arch to the vertical displacement of one support. The arch behaviour was analysed in the large displacement regime using both physical and numerical modelling. The experimental tests were performed on 1:10 small-scale models made of bi- component composite blocks with dry joints. In order to evaluate the geometrical accuracy of the blocks, two different sets of voussoirs were produced. The numerical simulations were carried out using a finite element (FE) micro-modelling approach, where the arch was modelled as an assembly of very stiff voussoirs connected by nonlinear interfaces. Particular attention was paid to the interface stiffness, which was set so as to tune the numerical model with the experimental evidence. Experimental and numerical results were then compared in terms of collapse mechanism, hinge configuration and ultimate displacement capacity. The imperfections of the physical models were found to significantly affect the arch response.

Full document

References

[1] Heyman, J. The stone skeleton. Structural engineering of masonry architecture. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1995).

[2] Ochsendorf, J. A. The masonry arch on spreading supports. Struct. Eng. (2006) 84(2):29- 35.

[3] Coccia, S., Di Carlo, F. and Rinaldi, Z. Collapse displacements for a mechanism of spreading-induced supports in a masonry arch. Int. J. Adv. Struct. Eng. (2015) 7(3):307-320.

[4] Di Carlo, F. and Coccia, S. Collapse state of elliptical masonry arches after finite displacements of the supports. Eng. Fail. Anal. (2020) 114.

[5] Galassi, S., Misseri, G., Rovero, L. and Tempesta, G. Failure modes prediction of masonry voussoir arches on moving supports. Eng. Struct. (2018) 173:706-717.

[6] Zampieri, P., Simoncello, N. and Pellegrino, C. Structural behaviour of masonry arch with no-horizontal springing settlement. Frat. ed Integrità Strutt. (2018) 12(43):182-190.

[7] Smars, P. Kinematic Stability of Masonry Arches. Adv. Mater. Res. (2010) 133-134:429- 434.

[8] Alforno, M., Monaco, A., Venuti, F. and Calderini, C. Validation of Simplified Micro- models for the Static Analysis of Masonry Arches and Vaults, Int. J. Archit. Herit. (2020).

[9] Masciotta, M-G., Pellegrini, D., Girardi, M., Padovani, C., Barontini, A, Lourenço, PB, Brigante, D. and Fabbrocino, G. Dynamic characterization of progressively damaged segmental masonry arches with one settled support: experimental and numerical. Frat. ed Integrità Strutt. (2020) 51:423-441.

[10] Ferrero, C., Rossi, M., Roca, P. and Calderini, C. Experimental and numerical analysis of a scaled dry-joint arch on moving supports. Int. J. Mason. Res. Innov. (2020).

[11] McInerney, J. and DeJong, M. J. Discrete Element Modeling of Groin Vault Displacement Capacity. Int. J. Archit. Herit. (2015) 9(8):1037–1049.

[12] Gilbert, M. and Melbourne, C. Rigid-block analysis of masonry structures. Struct. Eng. (1994) 72(21).

[13] Portioli, F. and Cascini, L. Large displacement analysis of dry-jointed masonry structures subjected to settlements using rigid block modelling. Eng. Struct. (2017) 148:485-496.

[14] Calderini, C., Lagomarsino, S., Rossi, M., De Canio, G., Mongelli, M.L. and Roselli, I. Shaking table tests of an arch-pillars system and design of strengthening by the use of tie- rods. Bull. Earthq. Eng (2015) 13(1):279–297.

[15] DeJong, M., De Lorenzis L., Adams, S. and Ochsendorf J.A. Rocking stability of masonry arches in seismic regions. Earthq. Spectra (2008) 2:847–865.

[16] Gaetani, A., Lourenço P. B., Monti, G. and Moroni, M. Shaking table tests and numerical analyses on a scaled dry-joint arch undergoing windowed sine pulses. Bull. Earthq. Eng. (2017) 15:4939-4961.

[17] Misseri, G., DeJong, M.J. and Rovero, L. Experimental and numerical investigation of the collapse of pointed masonry arches under quasi-static horizontal loading. Eng. Struct. (2018) 173:180-190.

[18] Shapiro E.E. Collapse mechanism of small-scale unreinforced masonry vaults. M.S. thesis in Building Technology, Massachusetts Institute of Technology (2012).

[19] Pippard A.J.S. and Ashby, R. An experimental study of the voussoir arch. J. Inst. Civ. Eng Journal of the Institution of Civil Engineers (1939) 10(3):383-404.

[20] Van Mele, T., McInerney, J., DeJong, M. and Block P. Physical and Computational Discrete Modelling of Masonry Vault Collapse,’ In: Proceedings of 8th International Conference on Structural Analysis of Historical Constructions, (2012), pp. 2552–2560.

[21] Quinonez, A., Zessin, J., Nutzel, A. and Ochsendorf J.A. Small-Scale Models for Testing Masonry Structures. Adv. Mater. Res. (2010) 133–134:497–502.

[22] Albuerne, A, Williams, M and Lawson V. Prediction of the failure mechanism of arches under base motion using DEM based on the NSCD method. Wiadomości Konserw (2013) 34:41–47.

[23] TNO DIANA BV. DIANA Finite Element Analysis User's Manual Release 9.6, Delft, The Netherlands (2014).

[24] Midas FX+ for DIANA, Customized Pre/Post-processor for DIANA (2013).