Simplified Seismic Vulnerability Assessment of Medieval Masonry Churches

Abstract

The meaningful seismic events occurred in Italy in the last decades showed the high vulnerability of monumental buildings and in particular of churches. In order to preserve such a precious heritage, operations aimed at the seismic risk mitigation based on the definition of suitable vulnerability assessment procedure are necessary. The high hazard of the Italian Peninsula and the huge amount of ecclesiastic buildings located in the exposed territories, stress the need to face the problem with innovative large-scale approaches. In this study, an architectural-engineering integrated procedure for the seismic assessment of existing masonry churches at a regional scale is proposed. Based on accurate historical investigation of typical Abruzzi churches, a typological characterization has been established, aimed at recognizing the common geometrical and constructive features of two types of medieval churches widespread in this area. Then, a numerical analysis has been carried out. In particular, by assuming simplified modelling hypotheses, two FE models representative of significant real cases have been implemented in Abaqus. By the elastic analyses, the main collapse mechanisms and the corresponding activation seismic accelerations have been determined. The obtained outcomes show an acceptable correspondence with the actual seismic damage revealed on similar churches in the aftermath of last seismic events, corroborating the reliability of the adopted integrated approach.

Full document

References

[1] Lagomarsino, S., Podestà, S. Seismic Vulnerability of Ancient Churches: II. Statistical Analysis of Surveyed Data and Methods for Risk Analysis. Earthquake Spectra (2004) 20(2):395–412.

[2] D'Ayala, D. Force and displacement-based vulnerability assessment for traditional buildings. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering (2005) 3(3):235-265.

[3] De Matteis, G, Brando, G, Corlito, V. Predictive model for seismic vulnerability assessment of churches based on the 2009 L’Aquila earthquake. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering (2019) 17(9):4909–4936.

[4] De Matteis, G, Zizi, M. Seismic Damage Prediction of Masonry Churches by a PGABased Approach. International Journal of Architectural Heritage (2019) 13 (7):1165–1179.

[5] Lourenco, P., Roque, J. Simplified indexes for the seismic vulnerability of ancient masonry buildings. Construction and Building Materials (2006) 20:200-208.

[6] Palazzi, N. C., Rovero, L., Llera, J., Sandoval, C. Preliminary Assessment on Seismic Vulnerability of Masonry Churches in Central Chile. International Journal of Architectural Heritage (2019). doi:10.1080/15583058.2019.1570388.

[7] Bartolini, S. L. Delle tipologie religiose nell’architettura abruzzese fra 11. e 19. secolo, Pescara: Tipolitografia SIGRAF. (2015). (In Italian).

[8] Gavini I. C. Storia dell’architettura in Abruzzo. Milano; Roma: Casa editrice d’arte Bestetti e Tumminelli. (In Italian).

[9] Di Nucci, A. L’arte di costruire in Abruzzo. Tecniche murarie nel territorio della diocesi di Valva e Sulmona Gange. (2011) (In Italian).

[10] Mancini, R. Le pietre aquilane: processi di approvvigionamento della pietra e sue forme di lavorazione nell’architettura storica. Roma: G.B.E. (2012) (In Italian).

[11] Lourenço, P. B. Computations on historic masonry structures. Progress in Structural Engineering and Materials (2002) 4:301-319.

[12] Brando, G., Criber, E. and De Matteis, G. The effects of L’aquila earthquake on the St. Gemma church in Goriano Sicoli: part II—fem analysis. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering 13:3733–3748 (2015).

[13] Kujawa, M., Lubowiecka, I. and Szymczak, C. Finite element modelling of a historic church structure in the context of a masonry damage analysis. Engineering Failure Analysis (2020) doi: 10.1016/j.engfailanal.2019.104233.

[14] Lourenço, P.B., Rots, J. and Blaauwendraad, J. Two approaches for the analysis of masonry structures: Micro and macro-modeling. HERON (1995), 40(4):313-340.

[15] De Matteis, G. and Mazzolani, F.M. The Fossanova church: seismic vulnerability assessment by numerical and physical testing. International Journal of Architectural Heritage (2010) 4(3):222-245.

[16] Bartolini Salimbeni, L. Architettura francescana in Abruzzo dal XIII al XVIII secolo. Edigrafica. (1993) (In Italian).