Extrados Strengthening of Single-Leaf Vaults Against Seismic Actions

Abstract

Single-leaf vaults are acknowledged among the most vulnerable components of historical masonry constructions with respect to earthquake loads, particularly when featuring large span to thickness ratios, as in the case of single leaf covering the main nave of churches. These elements often require structural strengthening against seismic actions. In this paper, two different extradostechniques are tested: lightweight plywood restraining elements and FRP laminates embedded in a lime mortar layer. The techniques are tested on single leaf vaults having a very unfavorable span to thickness ratio. A previous study on less slender vaults, showed that lightweight plywood centerings, applying passive confinement to the vault extrados, inhibit the onset of the typical four-hinges failure mechanism. This lightweight, dry solution can be easily prefabricated, transferred and assembled at the construction site. The technique is reversible and fully compliant with the major preservation principles. FRP is also effective against the onset of the failure mechanism but entails larger deformations of the retrofitted vault, which may be detrimental in the case of possible decorations. The solution requires special man labor to ensure correct smoothening and cleaning of the vault extrados and to trigger effective bond between the mortar and the vault extrados. Both solutions are shown to enable small relative displacements of the vault springing, which may follow the deformation of possible internal ties. The effectiveness of these retrofit techniques was comparatively verified through experimental tests on single-leaf barrel vault stripes at 1:2 scale subjected to cyclic distributed unsymmetrical loads and through comparison with the seismic response of a reference unreinforced single-leaf vault.

Full document

References

[1] Gulli, R., 1993, Le volte in folio portanti: tecnica costruttiva ed impiego nell’edilizia storica e moderna”, in: Proceedings of “I° Convegno Nazionale Manutenzione e Recupero nella città storica”, Rome. ARCO.

[2] Gulli, R. & Mochi G., 1995, “Bóvedas tabicadas: architettura e construzione”, in: “Il modo di costruire”, CDP editrice.

[3] Ochsendorf, J. & Freeman, M. (photographs), 2010, “Guastavino vaulting: the art of structural tile”, New York: Princeton Architectural Press.

[4] Heyman, 1966, “The stone skeleton”, International Journal of Solids and Structures 2, 249-279.

[5] O’Dwyer, D., 1999, “Funicular analyses of masonry vaults”, Computer & Structures, 73: 187-197.

[6] Ramage, M., Ochsendorf, J., Block, P. & Rich, P., 2008, "Advanced Geometry, Rudimentary Construction: Structural Form Finding for Unreinforced Thin-shell Masonry Vaults" in Advances in Architectural Geometry 2008, Vienna, Austria

[7] Block, P., DeJong, M. & Ochsendorf, J., 2006, “As hangs the flexible line: Equilibrium of masonry arches”. The Nexus Network Journal 8 (2), pp. 13-24.

[8] D’Ayala, D. and Tomasoni, E. 2008. The structural behaviour of masonry vaults: Limit state analysis with finite friction. Proceedings of the VI International Conference on Structural Analysis of Historical Constructions SAHC. 2-4 July, Bath, England. pp. 47-71. Ed. Taylor and Francis, London, UK.

[9] Giuriani, E. & Marini, A., 2008 “Experiences from the Northern Italy 2004 earthquake: vulnerability assessment and strengthening of historic churches”, Proceedings of the VI International Conference on Structural Analysis of Historical Constructions SAHC. 2-4 July, Bath, England. pp. 13-24. Ed. Taylor and Francis, London, UK.

[10] Giuriani, E., Marini, A., Porteri, C. & Preti, M., 2009 “Seismic vulnerability of churches associated to transverse arch rocking”, International Journal of Architectural Heritage, 3: 1–24, 2009. Ed. Taylor & Francis Group, LLC.

[11] Giuriani, E. & Marini, A., 2008, “Wooden roof box structure for the anti-seismic strengthening of historic buildings”, Journal of Architectural Heritage: Conservation, Analysis and Restoration, Vol.2(3) pp. 226-246.

[12] Ferrario, L., Marini, A., Riva, P. & Giuriani, E., 2009, “Traditional and Innovative Techniques for the Seismic Strengthening of Barrel Vaulted Structures Subjected to Rocking of the Abutments”, Proceedings of ATC-SEI Conference on Improving the Seismic Performance of Existing Buildings and Other Structures. San Francisco, California, December 9 -11.

[13] Ferrario, L., Marini, A., Riva, P. & Giuriani, E., 2010, “Proportioning criteria for traditional and innovative Extrados techniques for the strengthening of barrel vaulted structures subjected to rocking of the abutments”, Journal of Civil Engineering and Architecture, David Publishing Company, USA, pp.1-15. Vol. 4, N.5.

[14] Ferrario, L., Marchina, E., Marini., A., Preti, M. & Giuriani, E., 2010, “Lightweight ribs for the strengthening of single-leaf vaults undergoing seismic actions”, Proceedings of the VIII International Conference on Structural Analysis of Historical Constructions, Published in Advanced Materials Research, Vol.133-134, pp.923-928. Ed. Xianglin Gu and Xiaobin Song, China.

[15] Ferrario, L., 2013, “Masonry single-leaf barrel vaults: from the seismic vulnerability assessment to the proposal of an innovative retrofitting approach”, Ph.D. Thesis, University of Brescia.

[16] Marini, A., Giuriani, E., Belleri, A., Preti, M., Ferrario, L., 2016, “Plywood extrados retaining structures for the retrofit of single leaf vaults”, in: Proc. Of 16th International Brick and Block Masonry Conference "Masonry in a world of challenges", June 26 - 30, Padova, Italy

[17] Marini, A., Belleri, A., Preti, M., Riva, P., Giuriani, E., 2017, “Lightweight extrados restraining elements for the anti-seismic retrofit of single leaf vaults”, Engineering Structures, 141, 543-554

[18] Tomasoni, E., 2008, “Le volte in muratura negli edifici storici, Tecniche costruttive e comportamento strutturale”, Ph.D dissertation, University of Trento.

[19] Valluzzi, M., Valdemarca, M. & Modena, C., 2001, "Behavior of Brick Masonry Vaults Strengthened by FRP Laminates." Journal on Composite Construction, 10.1061/(ASCE)1090-0268(2001)5:3(163), 163-169.

[20] Girardello, P., Pappas A., da porto F., Valluzzi, M.R., 2013, “Experimental testing and numerical modelling of masonry vaults”. International Conference on Rehabilitation and Restoration of Structures, Chennai, 13-16 February 2013

[21] Giamundo, V., Lignola, G. P., Maddaloni G., Da Porto, F., Prota, A., Manfredi, G., 2016, “Shaking table tests on a full-scale unreinforced and IMG retrofitted clay brick masonry barrel vault”, Bull Earthquake Eng 14:1663–1693

[22] Giamundo V., Lignola G.P., Maddaloni G., Manfredi G., 2015, “Experimental investigation of the seismic performances of IMG reinforcement on curved masonry elements”. Compos Part B, Eng 70:53–63.