Reconstructed Overhanging Battlements. Executive Techniques and their Vulnerability in the Stronghold of Arquata del Tronto (Italy)

Abstract

The stronghold of Arquata del Tronto was heavily damaged by earthquakes in 2016 and it drew the attention of the experts in reinforcing historic buildings. They regarded it as a case study, a predicting model of the failure in employing specific construction elements in fortified architecture, whose geometric and material data were only approximately considered. The overhanging battlement is the most seriously damaged part of the building and has raised particular attention and interest. As often happens in other castles and fortresses, it dates back to the late 19th and even more to the 20th century. A first close examination of the building’s repairs shows how the new additions, whose maintenance is difficult, ended in failure. The additions were inspired by ancient details, but nonetheless they are unreasonable from the point of view of structure and durability: they – and even more the irrational repairs of the last decades – are the principal cause of failure. Material decay – closely linked to circumstances and places – has also played a decisive role. An extensive and rigorous historical research is necessary to find the sources and to evaluate their nature and limits, as well as to relate all information to the building, thus operating in close correlation with the building archaeology, by now a so widespread and consolidated research field. Jointly, the written documents and the building itself in its historical stratification allow a better analysis of the structural behaviour , an essential step to achieve an effective restoration planning.

Full document

References

[1] Pegoretti, G. Dei mastici. In: Id. Manuale pratico per l’estimazione dei lavori architettonici

[2] Viollet-le-Duc, E.E., Mâchicoulis. In: Dictionnaire raisonné de l’architecture française du XIeau XVIe siècle. Tome sixième, Bance (1863).

[3] Cerri, M.G., Biancolini, D. and Pittarello, L. (eds.), Alfredo d’Andrade, Tutela e restauro. Vallecchi (1981).

[4] Piper, O., Burgenkunde. Forschungen über gesammtes Bauwesen und Geschichte der Burgen innerhalb des deutschen Sprachgebietes. Ackermann (1895).

[5] Rocchi, E., Le fonti storiche dell’architettura militare, Officina Poligrafica, 1908.

[6] D’Altri, A. M., Castellazzi, G. and de Miranda, S. Collapse investigation of the Arquata del Tronto medieval fortress after the 2016 Central Italy seismic sequence. Journal of Building Engineering (2018) 18: 245-251.

[7] Ferretti, D., Coïsson, E. and Lenticchia, E. Seismic damage on merlons in masonry fortified buildings: a parametric analysis for overturning mechanism. Engineering Structures (2018) 177:117-132.

[8] Zippel, G. Le vite di Paolo II di Gaspare da Verona e Michele Canensi. Lapi (1904-11).

[9] Cordella, R. Arquata sotto la dominazione nursina. In: Piceno (1986) 1/2:11-32.

[10]Supplication of the Arquata Community, May 9th, 1655. In: Archivio di Stato di Roma (ASRm), Congregazione del Buon Governo, Serie II, Atti per luoghi, folder no. 263.

[11]Boschi, E., Guidoboni, E., Ferrari, G. and Valensise G. L. I terremoti dell’Appennino umbro marchigiano. Area sudorientale dal 99 a.c. al 1984, Compositori (1998).

[12]Various supplication of the Arquata Community, 1703-1711. In: ASRm, Congregazione del Buon Governo, folder no. 263.

[13]ASR, Congregazione del Buon Governo, folder no. 264.

[14]The Prefetto

[15]Giovanardi Bufferli, G., Risposta per la Rev.ma Camera apostolica contro la magnifica Comunità di Arquata, Lazzarini (1778). In: ASR, Camerale, Parte III, Comuni, Arquata, folder no. 267.

[16]Letter from the Congregazione del Buon Governo to the Delegato di Spoleto, May 9th,1815. In: Archivio di Stato di Ascoli Piceno (ASAP), Delegazione Prov. di Spoleto.

[17]Archivio di Stato di Ancona (ASAn), Sopr. delle Marche, Tutela, folder no. 94/a.

[18]Archivio Centrale dello Stato Roma (ACSR), Ministero della Pubblica Istruzione, Direzione Generale AA.BB.AA., III versamento, II parte, folder no. 536.

[19]ACSR, Ministero della Pubblica Istruzione, Direzione Generale AA.BB.AA., II versamento, folder no. 27.

[20]Archivio Biblioteca Comunale “Giulio Gabrielli” di Ascoli Piceno, Prefettura, folder no. 5-25, fasc. E6 – Rocca d’Arquata.

[21]David, P.F. Giuseppe Sacconi architetto restauratore (1854-1905). Gangemi (1990).

[22]Savorra, M. Giuseppe Sacconi. In: Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani. Vol. 89, Istituto della Enciclopedia Italiana (2017).

[23]Zacchilli, I. Icilio Bocci. In: Dizionario biografico dei Soprintendenti Architetti (1904-1974), Bononia University Press (2011), pp. 114-117.

[24]ACSR, Ministero della Pubblica Istruzione, Direzione Generale AA.BB.AA., III versamento, II parte, folder no. 536.

[25]Lampe, M., Dante Viviani. In: Dizionario biografico dei Soprintendenti Architetti (1904-1974), Bononia University Press (2011), pp. 615-618.

[26]ASAn, Archivio della Soprintendenza delle Marche, Tutela, folder no. 94/b.

[27]Gabrielli, G. Quaderno 18. In: Archivio Biblioteca Comunale “Giulio Gabrielli” di Ascoli Piceno, Fondo Gabrielli.

[28]D’Achille, P. I miracoli della “Cona Passatora”. Affreschi votivi con scritte in volgare in un santuario dell'Amatriciano. In: La Ricerca Folklorica (1995) 31:15-24.

[29]SABAP Marche, Archivio corrente, “Arquata del Tronto-Rocca”.

[30]ACSR, Ministero della Pubblica Istruzione, Direzione Generale AA.BB.AA., Ufficio Conservazione Monumenti (1953-1959), folder no. 30.

[31]ASAP, Genio Civile, folder no. 2435.